Wikipedia Rolling Out Article Rating System – What Do You Think?
Love it or hate it, you can’t say Wikipedia is slow to innovate. The giant encyclopedia site announced this weekend that it will now roll-out site-wide an article rating system that allows page visitors to rate an entry on a scale of 1 to 5 on trustworthiness, objectivity, completeness and quality of writing. Article raters have the option of self-identifying as a subject matter expert for whatever article they rate.
Wikipedia says that after limited testing of the feature, user response has been overwhelmingly positive; readers have said they found the rating system useful, that they felt compelled to give feedback and have been shown increasingly likely to begin editing articles for the first time after using the rating tool. Data about article ratings is also made available for export and outside analysis under a Creative Commons license.
Late last month, Wikipedia introduced a Love Button – a simple way for site users to give each other feedback on contributions to the site. The organization said that positive feedback was a key factor in new Editors coming back to continue improving the site. Making that feedback as easy as possible to give and receive is an important part of the site’s strategy to keep new editors engaged.
Rating articles looks like an even easier way for people to give feedback – and once you’ve started contributing that much, why not go a step further and improve the article you just rated?
That’s the funny thing about Wikipedia. More than six years ago, Wikipedia famously went head to head with the Encyclopedia Britannica in a study published in Nature magazine. The scientists who published the study found that in most, though not all, matters of fact and science – Wikipedia entries were superior to Britannica entries. That only begged the question: when they found areas the Wikipedia articles could be improved upon – did they hit the Edit button and do it?
That was six years ago; the site has grown and improved substantially since then. It’s grown more trusted and more used. Not everyone likes it, of course. See the comments on my post about the Love button, for example: some commenters called Wikipedia elitist, agenda-driven, filled with convenient untruths and they called me naive for calling the site an incredible asset to humanity.
We are, of course, all still figuring this internet thing out. Some of those critiques I would rate as low on objectivity but high on quality of writing, others as trustworthy but not terribly complete!
On balance I’ll call Wikipedia a big democratic net positive, with regular flashes of brilliance. I look forward to expressing that opinion in one through five starts, article by article, along with the millions of other opinionated people who regularly visit the site that strives for a neutral point of view.
Wikipedia says that after an initial test on 100,000 articles, the rating feature will now be rolled out in 370,000 page increments until it is live site-wide across 19 million articles, 3.6 of which are in English.
View full post on ReadWriteWeb
No comments yet.
No trackbacks yet.
May 15, 2013 - 6:55 pm
Amid a blizzard of announcements at its I/O conference, Google unveiled a major change to its core search product in singularly low-key fashion. Amit Singhal, a senior Google executive in charge of its search efforts, said that Google search, starting today, wouldn’t just answer the question implied in the words we type into that ubiquitous [...]
May 14, 2013 - 8:09 am
Last week, I was lucky to join a number of great speakers at the iLive conference in Riga, Latvia. As with all conferences, I learned a lot. (I simply can’t relate to those who go to a conference and say they’ve heard it all before.) I learned at least as much from the people I met [...]
May 9, 2013 - 4:55 am
Even wonder why it has taken so long for your robot butler to arrive? It’s 2013, why aren’t those long-promised robotic domestic servants helping out around the house yet? One reason for the delay: Robot engineers lacked a common platform on which to communicate and collaborate with one another. Robotic hardware and software systems had [...]
SEO News Writer and Publicist Hopeton Hewett Promotes His Article “20 Things … – PR.com (press release)
May 6, 2013 - 2:26 am
SEO News Writer and Publicist Hopeton Hewett Promotes His Article "20 Things …PR.com (press release)Mr. Hewett recently published an article title "20 Thing Your Publicist Is Not Doing" to inform business owners of the importance of SEO in press releases. "Press releases are an amazing tool in online marketing and will continue to be," says [...]
May 2, 2013 - 9:04 pm
Automated Rules have made it a lot more accessible for math savvy or other bright AdWords managers to set up a complex set of rules that can manage the bidding process in an AdWords campaign. Setting up rules for when a keyword should increase or decrease in value can be a huge relief for AdWords [...]
May 1, 2013 - 6:09 pm
Well look at that! Search traffic to news sites has dropped over the past eight months, according to how BuzzFeed tracks referrals to sites within its network. A change of user behavior? Or perhaps more the result of “Dark Google” and “Not Provided?” Come on, I’ll… Please visit Search Engine Land for the full article. [...]
May 1, 2013 - 4:08 pm
Well look at that! Search traffic to news sites has dropped over the past eight months, according to how BuzzFeed tracks referrals to sites within its network. A change of user behavior? More like the result of “Dark Google” and “Not Provided.” Come on, I’ll explain… Please visit Search Engine Land for the full article. [...]
April 29, 2013 - 9:08 am
With Google Now coming to iOS, a whole new audience using iPhones and iPads are about to meet Google’s predictive search service. It’s a feature that’s gone from interesting novelty to being downright amazing, in less than a year. Here’s a look at how the “predictive… Please visit Search Engine Land for the full article. [...]
April 29, 2013 - 6:55 am
Ditto is a 15-person eyewear startup that utilizes remarkable software — a 3D modeling system that replicates the buyer’s face — to let customers try on glasses virtually before purchasing them. Unfortunately for Ditto, its innovative software has put the company in the crosshairs of Glasses.com. Glasses.com is owned by 1-800 Contacts, a much larger online eyewear retailer [...]
April 18, 2013 - 1:04 pm
Today is a groundbreaking day for Google Bloggers. If you’re on G+ and you use Google’s blogging platform, Blogger, then you’re going to love this new update. Today they released their new Google + commenting system. I just recently started using a Blogger blog and when I heard about the new commenting system, I hurried [...]